Science


NASA image. Learn more at Wikipedia


See Other Articles
Writing Advice from Carl Sagan, Robert Heinlein &
Isaac Asimov


Hail, Discovery
When Science Meets Suspense

I am often asked whether certain concepts in my books are real or pure fantasy. One of the concepts I get the most questions about is the rotovator that was used to lift Jake and Carin off of Earth at the end of my book, Specific Impulse. I can assure you that not only is that concept real, it's not even very new or original.

The rotovator concept is a logical extension of the idea of a space elevator, also an old idea. The concept of the space elevator first appeared in 1895 when Russian scientist Konstantin Tsiolkovsky was inspired by the Eiffel Tower in Paris. Tsiolkovsky was a bit like Einstein in that he loved to do thought experiments. He imagined a cable with an Eiffel Tower on the top that reached up to geostationary orbit altitude. At 35,790 kilometers, or 22,238 miles above sea level, that would be some tower! He noted that his "celestial castle" at the top of the cable would be in orbit and folks could visit by an elevator that went up and down the cable. Simple! Problem solved – just give it to the engineers to implement.

Unfortunately, scientists don’t often consider the dirty little engineering problems. In this case, Our annoying little engineering problem is that we cannot build the cable. For a space elevator, depending on a whole bunch of details, the cable has to hold around 100,000 pounds per square inch of tension without degrading. Humans don't have any material that comes close to that. Also, there's the problem of all those satellites we already have in space. Eventually, any satellite below geostationary orbit will hit our cable. Not optimum at all.

So some folks began to think, "What if we turned the problem around? What if we had a big rock in orbit drop a line down, like a fishing line, and pull stuff up to orbit?" This, of course, alleviates some of the problems of the space elevator and introduces others. For example, a fishing line which just dropped straight down is going about 17,000 miles an hour across the surface of the Earth. This is faster than anything we are able to make. So we couldn't catch up to our cable. And let’s not even mention the sonic boom the cable would be producing.

Engineers back in the 1940’s scratched their heads and came up with several solutions. One of them was the rotovator. If you spin our rock in space at the right speed in the right direction, our line would drop straight down into the atmosphere, touch the Earth’s surface for a while (perhaps around 30 seconds), and go right back up again. Unfortunately, the line would have to take much more tension than even a space elevator. In short, we have all the technology to build a space elevator, and for that matter, a rotovator, except for one small piece. We still don't know how to build the cable. But when we do…